Best Replacement Windows of 2025

But even the least expensive models will set you back several hundred dollars apiece, plus installation costs. We test to see which models may be more worth the money by subjecting them to heavy rain and wind. 

We’ve tested wood, vinyl, and composite replacement windows from brands that include American Craftsman, Andersen, Atrium, Jeld-Wen, Marvin, Pella, and Simonton. Below are the top-scoring windows in each category.

Our guide to choosing replacement windows has more details on features and styles, as well as tips for finding an installer. You can also check out our ratings of over 20 replacement windows.

After you narrow down your options, you’ll also want to compare prices from different sources, including independent home centers, large retailers like Home Depot and Lowe’s, and contractors.